Text You Up -- Eagle Time Edition [R1 last question!]

Well, I'm going to make the executive decision to flip the order of the questions, because I did not expect that answer for the first question, so for sake of prolonging the humor...

What was the name of your first crush?

earthexe: Teddy
a52: None (sorry)
Gatr: Allen
Palamedes: Kirstie
Truegreen: Megan
Shredded: I
Kaynato: This is real difficult. I don't know if I had one.

One of these people had a different question, but who?
You have about three days to discuss amongst yourselves and vote who you think got the odd one out. And remember, the six of you telling the truth have to be unanimous to win in this round.