The Ocean: Re-Swabbed (Revival Contest) -Done and Stuff-

Who else is there?

The three off you briefly consider who of the crew is left to recruit.
Immediately springing to mind is Melons and her son since you already talked to her about it.
There's the third Buckbrother, Buckingham. Not to mention Buckshot still, technically.
And of course Cannon Fodder is right there.
Other than that there's Nailz, the ship's carpenter.

Go find the chef's son and have him take buckshot's place!

Out of those folks you decide that Squirt would probably be easy to recruit, and frankly the least useful, so no harm sticking him in the Nest to swap out with Buckshot.

But you never know where that scamp is. He doesn't have any duties to speak of.