Lucidstuck I

Alright, longtime lurker here, coming in to give my opinion on the the whole Alice thing.

I think we definitely should confront her, for several reasons.

-snip-

If you've ever met a spoiled brat, you know they won't just obey the moment you try to correct them. Spoiled brats throw tantrums, and the one we're dealing with could throw a tantrum with a meat cleaver. That's not something we want to have happen, weither or not it's happened before. Derrick didn't get possesed in any of the cycles either and we'd also like to keep that the same.

We don't have anything to gain out of causing this conflict, and it won't make the story more intresting if we make a bad descision just for the sake of it.

I'd also argue that Bob has no personality, as they're completely dependent on the reader's whims. We should leave plot advancement to the kids.

Edit:

And lets be real, Alice never listened to us in the first place. She doesn't respect us. We need to establish that we have something to hold over her, make her stop and think, or she will continue on the same path that she always does.

We don't have anything to hold over her though. Or do you think we could somehow leverage our knowledge of the rape for anything at all?