RE: dark subforum ideas thread: xxx edition
04-27-2016, 04:04 AM
you seem to be operating under the impression that it is necessary to have a separate proposition to repeal a proposition, but part of the beauty of the voting system as-is is that votes are never closed and you can repeal something already in-effect just by pushing it back under the 3-yes threshold (the yeshold, if you will allow me to portmanteau).
the neganaymeral is just net yesses, and for a negaprop you need to MEET the net yesses with a new batch of net nega-yesses (plus a maximum of 3 extra) whereas for a regular overturn you just need to meet the net posi-yesses, minus 3. since the proposal negatori does not take the already-existing overturning mechanism out-of-play, there's no reason anyone who wanted to overturn something would use it, since it only makes their goal harder. no on negatori
the neganaymeral is just net yesses, and for a negaprop you need to MEET the net yesses with a new batch of net nega-yesses (plus a maximum of 3 extra) whereas for a regular overturn you just need to meet the net posi-yesses, minus 3. since the proposal negatori does not take the already-existing overturning mechanism out-of-play, there's no reason anyone who wanted to overturn something would use it, since it only makes their goal harder. no on negatori