(10-26-2018, 05:02 AM)seedy Wrote: »

(10-26-2018, 04:21 AM)Mirdini Wrote: »honestly if I had to pick a third party claim that I think is a traitor at this point it'd be Thalia, because that seems like an absurdly difficult win condition + is great cover for an eavesdropping traitor role

like I pointed out, thalia’s wincon IS concomitant with the difficulty of other 3p wincons. Sol won when all living players had been both cursed AND cured by her (not to mention the fact that she handed out desperado badges when cursing, which makes the “living” part exponentially harder). RL as far as I understand needs to stump half of “all players,” something which may not actually be mathematically achievable even if there’s only 2 deaths per day/night cycle (sans other stump roles or item duplication).

if anything, thalia’s wincon is EASIER than what we’ve seen so far. so I more ir less believe it. that’s also why I question sunspider’s “I’m just a survivor” bit.
again, there's a reason I’ve been checking wincons :p

(11-08-2018, 05:39 AM)seedy Wrote: »ooh, I missed that post you made about people’s comments d1. I deeeeefinitely feel better about ac now. also thalia’s comments are definitely odd for someone who claimed 3p later, but otoh as far as I can tell neither Solaris nor pilot’s (nor my) role pm actually USE the words “third party.” Thalia miiiight not have actually known they were one until it was pointed out... not sure if they’ve played in any normal games.
JWatch worrying about “hostile 3ps” early d1 is definitely hmm

man, I can’t believe mirdini managed to shoot town when he could have shot almost anyone else and hit a 3p...

Quote:Thalia V1: Friendly (Numbers)

(12-09-2018, 05:26 PM)LegendaryQ Wrote: »When I have more time (I am starting a game today...) or when someone else wants, some votal analysis reg. Thalia should be done. In particular, I'm curious about Day 6's Sunspider lynch train since we knew she was a 3rd party.

Reyweld: To be clear, Sunspider was killed but survived?

(12-09-2018, 05:02 PM)Reyweld Wrote: »Sunspider Rolls Fuzzy Dice

Sunspider has been killed!

Sunspider Rolls Fuzzy Dice

Sunspider got a prize!

(12-09-2018, 10:41 PM)LegendaryQ Wrote: »Uh, Reyweld literally said they were a "benign 3P". It was the delayed celebrity part of their role. Do you want me to fetch the post?

(10-23-2018, 06:00 PM)Reyweld Wrote: »(Delayed) Celebrity Role Call

Sunspider is the Advice Columnist, aka the CultistJailerCopDoctorBlocker RechargingTanker Beloved-Princess LostChest DelayedCelebrity who is a Benign 3P (Third Party).