+- Eagle Time (https://eagle-time.org)
+-- Forum: Cool Shit You Can Do (https://eagle-time.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Forum Games (https://eagle-time.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Thread: Nostalgfia - GAME OVER SCUM WIN (/showthread.php?tid=3153)
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Schazer - 07-21-2018
Please be careful leaving votes on people if you're not actively attending to the thread. We could have a situation with third party survivors whose best interest is to rush votes to a mislynch
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Robust Laser - 07-21-2018
Yeah, Group Investigator is specifically the name of my role and quicktopic and everything
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Robust Laser - 07-21-2018
oh it COULD be one mafia. Maybe? I don't know. One mafia would be extremely pleasant. hello how does this game work. as schazer said, mylo doesn't make a lot of sense with one maf, right?
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Robust Laser - 07-21-2018
but if it's two and schazer is slated to die of poison, it'd be lylo wouldn't it
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Schazer - 07-21-2018
Also if it's two it'd just be straight mylo not conditional mylo
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Schazer - 07-21-2018
One scum, two poisoned town, mislynch non-poisoned town and there's three deaths in the night would get us to d8 overrun
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Robust Laser - 07-21-2018
I currently feel extremely strongly about Pharmacy so unless somebody can present like, really good evidence towards Reyweld being scum, I'm sticking to my vote. It has to be either Pharmacy or Reyweld.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Acionyx - 07-21-2018
Votes:
Pharmacy: (2) (Reyweld, Robust Laser)
Reyweld: (1) (Pharmacy)
Abstaining: (3) (Schazer, Wheat, Palamedes)
4 to lynch
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Schazer - 07-21-2018
I'm starting to feel the most plausible scenario is 3p survivor with one scum which, gross!
After a mislynch that's 1+1 vs 3 town, with a nk and poisoning death d8 will be 1+1 vs 1. Survivor gets to kingmake if the game doesn't end then and there.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Robust Laser - 07-21-2018
Went to verify claims, a miller would appear wrong to a rolecop too, yeah? No? All the other Reyweld claims have been accurate.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Robust Laser - 07-21-2018
I mean, I know they're a real rolecop because that's the only way to have gotten my role name correct. So, yeah, probably?
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Pharmacy - 07-21-2018
Is the guess involving me.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Pharmacy - 07-21-2018
I mean do you really believe soli. That I have poison. Sure they were a thief, but they were also a 3rd party lyncher. There is plenty of good reason why she lied bout me having poison.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Pharmacy - 07-21-2018
If I'm gonna have the noose, then at least it will definitely throw shade on reyweld. Ha!
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Pharmacy - 07-21-2018
God, I didn't consider pala being a nexus being possibility. I was so hyperfocused on reyweld bc he keeps voting on me for the past days.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Robust Laser - 07-21-2018
I mean right now like, I know there's not a lot of hard evidence here but me and Reyweld can't be scum-allied unless we've got two maf, which as outlined by schazer (who like, sure, this is where the suspicion is from you) is unlikely. And he was able to confirm my role, which like, I'd hope would be pretty good for if not proving me to be what I claimed, at least more likely. And if I'm telling the truth, and the 1-scum theory is also true, then Schazer can not be in the mafia.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Robust Laser - 07-21-2018
Reyweld could absolutely be a mafia rolecop gaining my trust be confirming my role to help direct things at Not Him, but I'm currently opting for the simpler possibility of our busdriver being the scum of the two.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Robust Laser - 07-21-2018
(Conditional) LYLO was announced, so now seems like the kind of time you'd expect somebody to make a claim that would put you in the line of fire if there were another day to follow. But I know either Pharmacy or Reyweld has to be in the mafia, and I will not accept any alternatives unless somebody's got a secret redirect up their sleeve that completely changes my night 3 investigation information.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Schazer - 07-21-2018
Still don't know why n-o died unless mirdini was lying through his teeth about being role blocked
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Schazer - 07-21-2018
Also Wheat I have had my magical gun all game and any attempts to steal it merely have it wind back up in my inventory by the end of the night. The item description is pretty explicit as is the description for Ammo. You saw yourself that my ammo went walkabout???
Still want to hear from Palamedes
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Robust Laser - 07-21-2018
yeah it's one of the main reasons I'm totally open to swapping to Reyweld. I'm real glad that Reyweld confirmed my role, but at a potential lylo that's an easy gambit to see happening. I went checking that specifically to see what order it happened in and the swap was claimed before the comparison was claimed. Both were in my investigate so... hm.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Schazer - 07-21-2018
(07-21-2018, 06:42 AM)Wheat Wrote: »Conditional mylo could mean that there are two mafia left. If a mislynch occurs and a poisoned mafia is healed while a nightkill goes through, it would be 2 v 2 (or 2 v 1 v 1).
A mislynch here on a 1 v 1 v 4 situation would still not result in loss for town unless the killer automatically wins with 3 left. If that's the case, I hope that happens over the mafia winning.
if it's two scum it's presumably palamedes and one of reyweld+pharmacy imo
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Schazer - 07-21-2018
Quote:Pharmacy: (2) (Reyweld, Robust Laser)
Reyweld: (1) (Pharmacy)
Abstaining: (3) (Schazer, Wheat, Palamedes)
4 to lynch
Thinking about scum bumrush on the Pharmacy lynch:
Palamedes has been online since Aci last put these votals up.
Ergo if Pharmacy is town, the final two scum players are not a Wheat+Palamedes combo (as they absolutely would've lynched the redirector who could've hecked their plans up). One of them could still be scum (probably Palamedes; Wheat could be 3p?) Admittedly this is not terribly useful information but. Still.
Current claims that I'm feeling pretty town about:
- Schazer - Mason+Vigilante. Lost ammo on N1 and has been mostly useless since.
- Robust Laser - Group Investigator (as correctly named by Reyweld). Has a not-scum on Wheat, scum on one of Reyweld+Pharms.
- Wheat - Lousy Mailman. Role corroborated by night action hell; declared not-scum by investigator.
Claims from sturdiest to shakiest:
- Reyweld - Rolecop, corroborated by correctly naming Laser's role. Role not-inconsistent with being scum.
- Pharmacy - Busdriver, corroborated. Setup not-inconsistent with the role being a scum role.
- Palamedes - Role thus far not able to be corroborated. Quite possibly a load of crock. Would very much like to hear what he got up to last night.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Palamedes - 07-21-2018
(07-20-2018, 11:17 PM)Schazer Wrote: »I'd like a claim on who shot n-o.
Hi, I redirected towards n-o, jesters don't just survive when they get lynched. Either n-o was going to become town or scum and would have been lynched regardless.
I was online yes, but that's because I just left the site open on my computer, not because I was actually around.
Conditional MYLO means that both a one scum and a two scum world are technically possible because of poison I think. I'm guessing the former to be honest because poison more than likely means death now with (probably) no more new items kicking around. That means if scum is poisoned we have at most one left alive tomorrow with at least three left alive, so not really MYLO. Who is poisoned at this point?
RE: Nostalgfia Day 7 - double date with death - Palamedes - 07-21-2018
If we do exist in a one remaining scum world Pharmacy makes a lot more sense, since busdriver is the strongest role remaining and having a traitor means that having a rolecop would be kind of weird. Schazer makes less sense too because with a gun and ammo being a loose cannon (mafia that doesn't know their teammates) was the most likely option for being mafia and a serial killer with the ability to lose their killing power would be strange too.
If two remain a lot of cards are still on the table, though the remaining scum is still likely within the Pharmacy/Reyweld/Laser group. I'd bet on Reyweld and Laser being together but Reyweld/Pharmacy being forced to hyperbus or having two blind mafioso (n-o and Schazer) would be possible as well.