+- Eagle Time (https://eagle-time.org)
+-- Forum: Cool Shit You Can Do (https://eagle-time.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Forum Games (https://eagle-time.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Thread: Nostalgfia - GAME OVER SCUM WIN (/showthread.php?tid=3153)
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Granolaman - 05-11-2018
Whoops I think I totally misread the redirect pile. I thought wheat's attempted action on me got redirected back to himself, but he actually self-targeted so the Granola-Schazer swapper is not in the group a52 saw?
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Mirdini - 05-11-2018
Yeah, I think that's the implication
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Granolaman - 05-11-2018
dang I thought I was popular
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Palamedes - 05-11-2018
Solaris no not yet(?) and I don't want to go into it until that point.
RE: busdriving - If a52 visited Wheat they would have been redirected the same as everyone else, and so would have seen all of those people. Busdrivers don't selectively work or fail with certain roles as far as I know. Also apparently granola/Schazer might have been targeted but the point stands it's tied up there and not on Coldblooded.
I personally don't want to take a chance on n-o (less obvious lynch momentum against CSJ with only part of the day left, and also highest chance of being town among all of the three main targets) or waste a lynch on CSJ (likely 3rd party and still less chance of being scum than Cold) and vastly prefer the idea of scum being down a role earlier as soon as possible. I also wouldn't be surprised by scum having some sort of protective role (possibly on top of their redirector). Which means that Coldblooded basically needs to be lynched at this point unless you want to leave her for later when the scum protective role(s) are dead.
Wheat if you think me being town means Coldblooded should immediately be lynched, I'd like to hear what makes you think otherwise.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Solaris - 05-11-2018
yeah ok this clarification helps its, a big mess
its too bad n-o didnt come back to weigh in but! lmao
again, caint wait to find out what the fuck happened every night, not looking forward to tonights magic either
![[Image: G6bdz0p.png]](https://i.imgur.com/G6bdz0p.png)
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Cat - 05-11-2018
oh my god can we fuckin move past it already????
if you want me to explain what happened with the items I will otherwise i t i s d e a d d i s c u s s i o n
vote: coldblooder
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Mirdini - 05-11-2018
Cool so yeah rn I’d put down CB as mafia assuming Pala’s cop is legit (inclined to think it is), Nercania as probable mafia, CSJ as probable 3P & maybe mafia, wheat as town (as annoying as arguing with the dog has been I think they are being a helpful dog/townish :P), pala as town assuming pala’s cop is legit, schaz as 3Pish, granola/sunspider as townish
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Cat - 05-11-2018
(05-10-2018, 06:27 AM)Mirdini Wrote: »Folks I feel town-ish on right now: Cat, Sunspider, wheat, a52
I did it
I'm dratini's top town read in a game
for the first time ever
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Mirdini - 05-11-2018
Oh right Cat also pretty townish
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - awkwardcarapace - 05-11-2018
Okay, this is pretty interesting, I’d be willing to consider a switch vote to CB but only is Pala is totally sure that CB is a BadFriend. Only problem is, it’s really late in the day right now and not everyone might catch wind of this, and not enough people might switch to CB to get a lynch. This simultaneously might make the vote count for CSJ to dip below the needed amount to lynch and then NOBODY might get lynched today. That’s not very optimal for if we have two suspects...
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Mirdini - 05-11-2018
There are definitely enough people around to lynch CB in the next 16 hours, aC
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Solaris - 05-11-2018
some ppl figured it out but im dumb so
i dont super want to let csj go but
Unvote, Vote: coldblooded
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Mirdini - 05-11-2018
(05-11-2018, 02:50 AM)Wheat Wrote: »*dog barks! dog barks heartily! you can tell with the fire in their eyes that
Someone please keep this dog from the wine barrels, this cannot be good for the dog's liver
if the item is not sane then palamedes flipping town would not at all clarify that, so the only route where waiting makes sense is if you suspect pala of being scum lying about it
also you are calling CB an 'isolated player' when she has had a lot more interactions than your prior favored lynch, nercania? She is just as good of an info source
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Palamedes - 05-11-2018
Oh specifically I was told that Coldblooded was mafia, not a more generic 'scum' or 'bad'. This makes me feel pretty confident that she's not third party either. Regardless I'm checking if they would or wouldn't apply in my QT now since it completely slipped my mind and I'll let you all know when I find out.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Palamedes - 05-11-2018
Missed this page.
I like info lynches and all but I find them always less preferable to actually killing scum. The more likely someone is mafia the less likely they are to 'conveniently' die in the night and the more suspicious and/or info giving bodies drop the better.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Sunspider - 05-11-2018
TBH, I'm a little grumpy on voting without having an item name to back this claim up, but I get it. And it's hard to see a gambit where Palamedes is Mafia, and is so set on getting a Townie killed at the cost of their own life, that such a gambit would make any sense at all.
SUNSPIDER:
Sudden upheaval!
A self-sacrificing claim.
We Vote: Coldblooded.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Mirdini - 05-11-2018
For the record I'm well aware of the possible scenario where Palamedes is actually scum and is doing a goofy-ass 1-shot cop claim to get a free lynch and possibly get away with it but
a. that draws a *ton* of attention to him that will not peel off anytime soon, especially if CB flips town (going 'whoops, guess the item wasn't sane! D:' is not going to fly, I don't think) and even if not
b. Pala's play today has felt pretty town to me, CB's play so far has not
c. S'possible Pala is doing the ULTRA TEAMMATE BUSSING strategy, so if CB flips scum I'm definitely not calling Palamedes entirely clear but hey, I'll take a free scum lynch even if it's scum trying to hand me one :P
d. fundamentally it comes down to, do we trust palamedes here or do we not, and I think I'm willing to trust him given what's gone down so far.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Mirdini - 05-11-2018
It's More Votals
Coldblooded: (5) (Palamedes, Mirdini, Cat, Solaris, Sunspider)
CSJ: (4) (Schazer, Awkwardcarapace, Seedy, Robust Laser)
Nercania: (2) (Wheat, Akumu)
Pharmacy: (2) (Coldblooded, A52)
Wheat: (1) (Nercania)
Abstaining: (5) (AgentBlue, Pharmacy, Robbobt, Granola, CSJ)
With 19 alive it takes 10 to hardlynch and 4 to softlynch.
Countdown to Day End
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Solaris - 05-11-2018
there might be items not in the database yet i think, which is! fair enough
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Granolaman - 05-11-2018
Vote: Coldblooded That puts us at 5 right?
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - awkwardcarapace - 05-11-2018
(05-11-2018, 02:59 AM)Palamedes Wrote: »Oh specifically I was told that Coldblooded was mafia, not a more generic 'scum' or 'bad'. This makes me feel pretty confident that she's not third party either. Regardless I'm checking if they would or wouldn't apply in my QT now since it completely slipped my mind and I'll let you all know when I find out.
!?!
Honestly still rubs me the wrong way how fast this turnaround went but... here we go! vote: coldblooded
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - awkwardcarapace - 05-11-2018
Mirdini's points in post #610 makes me feel a little less rubbed
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Mirdini - 05-11-2018
In that same quote CSJ is saying "[Coldblooded] may be onto something with Nercania-Orccelga", so that post is as much endorsing CB as a non-scum read as it is a scum read. That's also exactly the kind of waffly scum-pointing team'd scum do early in the game so they can disavow each other if one flips scum later.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Mirdini - 05-11-2018
Also because 20% of 19 is 3.8 the soft lynch is actually at 4, funnily enough.
We definitely have a plurality on CB now, though. Might as well not hammer it and see if she can get in and say something about the lynch before the year-guillotining happens.
RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time - Palamedes - 05-11-2018
The weird CSJ/Sunspider/Coldblooded triangle is one of the primary reasons I've wanted all three of them dead for a while, which is another reason why I preferred those lynches to n-o. It's seemed like (especially considering Coldblooded's smaller amount of posts) they're all drawn together fairly often and in a way that I've been trying to sort out but looks like potential alignment (but probably not between all three).
ac the reason the turnaround was fast is because it's a guilty, that's (almost always) a sure thing and lynching scum is the name of the game. As for why it's happening so late, I deliberately held back a the result as long as felt safe. If I had dropped it earlier in the day the lynch would have progressed more naturally as opposed to jumping off someone sure, but we would have lost a lot of the progress we made today on CSJ and others.